Wigan boss unhappy at uneven treatment between Kalvin Phillips and Joe Williams

Add as preferred source on Google

Leeds United went top of the Championship yesterday with a 2-0 win over Wigan Athletic at the DW Stadium. Two goals from Patrick Bamford saw Leeds win the fixture comfortably, although they were helped by the sending off of Wigan midfielder Joe Williams in the first-half.

Wigan manager Paul Cook had no complaints about that decision. However, he did feel his player was treated differently to Leeds United midfielder Kalvin Phillips. 

Phillips committed a similar foul to Williams but received no punishment. Cook, as reported by the Yorkshire Evening Post, took exception to that decision.

---

“Are we aggrieved at the sending off? No. I did think it was a second yellow, without a doubt.

“But are we aggrieved with the decision just before, when (Kalvin) Phillips commits a very similar foul, and no yellow? Yes, we are.

“All we’re asking for as managers is for referees to show consistency in a game – that’s all we’re asking for.”

TBR’s View

It is clear to see why Cook might have been frustrated. Phillips’ challenge could have easily been perceived as a yellow card and Leeds fans certainly know that their midfield talisman plays on the edge. 

However, on second viewing, Williams’ challenge on Bamford which saw him receive a second yellow could have easily been a straight red regardless. In that respect, Wigan can hardly have any complaints about the fact Williams was given his marching orders. 

As for Phillips, he knows he walks a tightrope with some of his challenges. However, it is unlikely that he will be changing his style anytime soon and Leeds fans will hope that is the case.