Connect with us

Stoke City

The three reasons behind Mark Hughes’ Stoke City dismissal

Martyn Cooke



Photo: Reuters

Mark Hughes became the latest high-profile managerial casualty of the season when he was sacked by Stoke City just hours after the club had been knocked out of the FA Cup by League Two side Coventry City.

The result marked a new low point in what has been an increasingly turbulent, disappointing and concerning season for supporters and with The Potters having slipped into the relegation zone less than seven days earlier it was no surprise to see the club hierarchy dismiss their Welsh manager.

Hughes had been one of the longest serving managers in the Premier League prior to his dismissal and although his time in The Potteries ended on a sour note the 54-year-old should look back on his four-and-a-half years at the club with some pride.

He led Stoke to three consecutive top-ten finishes in the top flight for the first time in almost a century and helped to reinvent the team’s playing style, switching to a more possession-based philosophy after the direct football employed by his predecessor Tony Pulis.

However, the last eighteen months have seen a gradual decline in performances and results eventually culminating in Hughes being relieved of his duties. Here, The Boot Room looks at three reasons why Stoke decided to part company with ‘Sparky’.

Poor performances and results

Football managers are ultimately judged on the results and performances that they can inspire out on the pitch and in the last eighteen months they quite simply have not been good enough under Mark Hughes.

The Potters currently sit eighteenth in the Premier League table and have been sliding towards the relegation zone since mid-November.

In addition to this, the team were knocked out of both domestic cup competitions at the first time of asking after being defeated by Bristol City in the League Cup and by League Two side Coventry City in the FA Cup on Saturday.

Ultimately this has led to supporters having little to look forward to for the remainder of the season barring a relegation battle.

However, it was the manner of the performances, rather than the results themselves, that ultimately led to Hughes’ demise. Stoke have the worst defensive record of any team in any of Europe’s top-flight divisions and have been conceding over two goals per game on average so far this campaign.

The team have been on the receiving end of a number of hammerings, including against Manchester City (7-2), Tottenham Hotspur (5-1) and Chelsea (4-0 and 5-0), which has been further exacerbated by defeats to clubs in the bottom half of the table, exemplified by home losses against Bournemouth (2-1), Newcastle United (1-0) and West Ham United (3-0).

Results and performances were not acceptable for a team that has now spent a decade in the top flight and there has been little in recent weeks to suggest that Hughes was capable of turning Stoke’s fortunes around.

A loss of identity

Two years after his appointment Mark Hughes had built a Stoke City team that had a clear identity.

The Welshman had implemented a new style of play that promoted possession-based football and dynamic attacking play, far removed from the direct approach adopted by his predecessor Tony Pulis, with players such as Xherdan Shaqiri, Marko Arnautovic and Bojan Krkic providing the flare and creativity.

The Potters ripped apart Manchester City and Manchester United during December 2015 with the team being referred to by the media as ‘Stoke-alona’ as Hughes’ vision for the club began to take shape.

However, defeat in the League Cup semi-final against Liverpool in early 2016 appeared to signal the decline in Stoke’s fortunes. Results and performances began to deteriorate and the possession-based football slowly began to be eroded and replaced by a reliance on long balls and crosses towards Peter Crouch. Arnautovic and Bojan both departed the club and soon the team had lost all sense of identity, stumbling along from week-to-week.

Hughes clearly did not know what his best team was and this was reflected in the constant switching of personnel and formation. His decision to switch to a 3-4-3 formation at the start of the season, despite having no adequate wing-backs in the squad, was incredibly naïve on reflection and supporters were left scratching their heads watching striker Mame Biram Diouf effectively being shoe-horned in as a right-back.

In the final months of his reign Hughes had reverted to a 4-5-1 system with the team aimlessly lumping direct balls in the direction of an isolated Peter Crouch. The ‘Stoke-a-lona’ identity was long gone.

Errors in the transfer market

The gradual decline in Stoke City’s fortunes on the pitch has occurred in parallel with an increasing number of failures and mistakes in the transfer market. Whilst Mark Hughes should be credited for bringing the likes of Bojan Kirkic and Marko Arnautovic to The Potteries for minimal fees in his debut season his more recent signings have been catastrophic.

Club record signing Giannelli Imbula was signed for in excess of £18 million in January 2016 but, despite a bright start to his Stoke career, he quickly found himself frozen out of the first team squad altogether and is currently on loan a Toulouse.

Likewise, Saido Berahino was purchased for £12 million from Midlands rivals West Bromwich Albion in order to solve the club’s goal scoring dilemma but instead the striker has failed to hold down a regular first team spot and has yet to find the net in his first year with the club.

In short, Hughes has wasted significant amounts of money in recent transfer windows on players that have made absolutely no impact at the club. These failing have been further exacerbated by the 54-year-old’s failure to address some of the key issues that have undermined Stoke’s performances this season, with his refusal to purchase natural wing-backs in the summer, despite using a 3-4-3 formation, an especially bizarre error of judgement.

Martyn is currently a PTA and Research Assistant in the Department of Exercise Science at the Manchester Metropolitan University (MMU). In addition to his teaching role he is also undertaking a PhD in Sports History that is exploring the origins and development of football in Staffordshire. Prior to working at MMU, Martyn spent a decade operating in the sport and leisure industry in a variety of roles including as a Sports Development Officers, PE Teacher, Football Coach and Operation Manager.

Stoke City

How Stoke have become early favourites for promotion

Martyn Cooke



Photo: Getty Images

Loyalty is a commodity that is in short supply in modern football.

The age of players spending their entire careers at one team or managers building a club over a period of time spanning decades is long gone.

Instead, the contemporary game is characterised by players that jump from club to club in search of regular game time or more money and a ‘managerial merry-go-round’ in which over half of managers in English football’s top four tiers will either be sacked or resign by the end of the season.

For players especially, the focus is on being in the Premier League. That is where the glitz, glamour, talent and, ultimately, money is located and there tends to be limited loyalty if a club is relegated from the top tier.

Which makes the recent developments at Stoke City come as a pleasant surprise.

The Potters were relegated in May after a decade-long spell in the Premier League and the general perception was that the club would be stripped of its prized assets over the summer.

Jack Butland, Joe Allen, Xherdan Shaqiri and pretty much anyone else who possessed a significant reputation was linked with a move away from the Bet365 Stadium.

(Photo by Tony Marshall/Getty Images)

The fear for supporters was that there would be some kind of fire-sale, leaving the new manager with the unenviable task of starting from scratch and building an almost entirely new squad.

However, that simply has not been the case.

Yes, Xherdan Shaqiri was sold to Liverpool last week, although that was to be expected after it was revealed that he had a relegation-release clause that made him available for just £13 million, and his departure was proceeded by the sales of Ramadan Sobhi and Lee Grant.

But, beyond that, there has been a surprising level of loyalty shown by the majority of the squad.

Gary Rowett’s most impressive feat since being appointed as manager at the start of the summer has not been who he has bought in the transfer window, but rather who he has been able to convince to remain at the Bet365 Stadium.

Joe Allen, who was named in the team of tournament at the European Championships just two years ago, was the first to sign a new long-term deal and commit his future to the club. The Welsh midfielder certainly would not have been short of options this summer and his decision to remain is a significant statement of intent.

He was then followed by Moritz Bauer, who signed a new contract earlier this month. The 26-year-old only arrived in January but has been quick to commit to the challenge of securing promotion from the Championship despite being hugely impressive during his 15 appearances in the Premier League last season.

Furthermore, Peter Crouch has signalled his intention to stay after suggesting that he had ‘unfinished business’, whilst the likes of Ryan Shawcross, Bruno Martins Indi, Eric Pieters and Mame Biram Diouf all appear willing to stay.

Rowett revealed over the weekend that he is hoping to convince Bojan Krkic to remain at the club and return to his best after his loan spell in Spain ended and there are whispers that Jack Butland might also be willing to scrap it out for a year in the second tier.

Somewhat bizarrely, it is not inconceivable that Stoke will start the campaign with a stronger, more balanced squad of players than the one that ended the previous season in the Premier League.

It is perhaps no surprise to see Stoke among the favourites with betting companies to be promoted although there is certainly still plenty of work to be done.

However, Rowett has started to build an intimidating squad of players that is full of experience and quality. He has not achieved this through splashing vast arrays of cash in the transfer marker, but rather by convincing existing big-name players to remain at the club.

Continue Reading

Stoke City

Gary Rowett opens the door for Robert Huth’s return to Stoke

Martyn Cooke



Robert Huth
Photo: Getty Images

Stoke City boss Gary Rowett has opened the door for Robert Huth to return to the club on a permanent basis as the central defender continues to train with the first team squad as he attempts to regain his fitness.

The German was released by Leicester City at the end of last season following a hugely successful three-year stint at the King Power Stadium which included their historic Premier League title triumph in 2016.

Subsequently, he approached Stoke at the start of the summer and has been allowed to train with Rowett’s squad whilst he looks for a new club.

Huth remains a popular figure at the Bet365 Stadium having made over 150 appearances for The Potters over the period of half-a-decade following a £5 million transfer from Middlesbrough in 2009.

The 33-year-old formed a dominant central defensive partnership with Ryan Shawcross that provided the solid foundation on which the club’s modern success was built.

(Photo by Michael Regan/Getty Images)

The notion of Huth re-signing for Stoke is a romantic concept, one that many Stoke supporters will be keen to see, and Rowett told the Stoke Sentinel that the door is still open for the German defender.

“He’s coming to train. We’ll see how it is for both parties and we’ll assess it as we go along … We’ll try to help him and that’s where we are at the moment. I don’t think there’s any real rush to make a decision.”

“There’s no strings attached for either party but come in and train, we’ll get you involved – we’re a little bit short in terms of numbers in that area anyway.”

Stoke are currently short of central defensive options following the departures of Kevin Wimmer (on loan to Hannover 96), Marc Muniesa (who has signed for Girona) and Kurt Zouma (who returned to Chelsea following the conclusion of his loan spell) as the club adapts to life outside the Premier League.

With that in mind, Huth’s availability as a free agent and his pre-existing standing within the club makes him an attractive option as Rowett continues to re-mould his squad in preparation for the new season. He has already featured heavily in Stoke’s early pre-season activities and fixtures whilst he is also likely to be joining the club on their tour of Germany.

However, Rowett is right to be cautious about signing the German defender.

Huth did not make a single appearance for Leicester last season as he struggled with a string of injuries and fell considerably down the pecking order at the King Power Stadium whilst, at 33 years of age, he is stepping into the twilight of his career.

Could he realistically adapt to the physical demands of the Championship where there is a requirement to play two matches most weeks as part of a demanding fixture schedule?

Furthermore, Stoke should be looking to the future rather than attempting to recreate previous glories.

(Photo by Michael Regan/Getty Images)

Whilst Huth remains a legend in the eyes of supporters he would only provide a short-term solution and will undoubtedly return as a very different player than the one that last played at the Bet365 Stadium in 2015.

Rowett is quite rightly looking to bring in a new generation of young, fresh and hungry talent which will be led by new signing Oghenekaro Etebo, Nigeria’s 21-year-old World Cup star. Does Huth fit within those parameters? Probably not.

Whilst Huth’s return may be a somewhat romantic notion that would certain provide a short-term solution to the club’s lack of defensive cover, on a practical level which looks at the long-term in would leave much to be desired.

Ultimately, much may depend, as it so often does in football, on money.

Stoke have already made significant moves in the transfer market following the arrivals of Etebo and Benik Afobe whilst they have been linked with a string of other big-money signings.

Without the safety net of Premier League TV revenue the signing of Huth on a free transfer could allow Rowett to focus his investment on strengthening other areas of the team.

So the door is certainly open for Huth to return on a permanent basis, although Rowett will need to decide whether his focus is on the short-term or long-term future of the club.

Continue Reading

Stoke City

Do Stoke City have the Championship’s best full-back in Moritz Bauer?

The Austrian signed a new deal at the Bet365 Stadium earlier this month.

Martyn Cooke



Photo: Getty Images

The Bet365 Stadium has been a hive of activity over the summer so far as Stoke City prepare for life outside the top-flight for the first time in a decade.

The Potters were relegated from the Premier League in May but the club have been quick to begin to address some of the issues, mistakes and frailties that underpinned their failures last season and, arguably, can be traced back throughout the previous twenty-four months.

Gary Rowett was appointed as manager at the start of the summer and his arrival was seen as something of a coup after Stoke were able to persuade the 44-year-old to leave Championship rivals Derby County.

He moved quickly to secure the impressive signings of Benik Afobe and Nigeria’s World Cup star Oghenekaro Etebo whilst Joe Allen was also convinced to sign a new contract that saw him pledge his long-term future to the club.

All of these events have been widely discussed but something that many media outlets failed to highlight was that Stoke have also been able to sign the best fullback in the Championship.

It was announced at the start of July that Moritz Bauer had signed a new long-term deal that will see him remain at the Bet365 Stadium until 2023.

The Austrian defender may not be the most instantly recognisable name in English football yet Stoke supporters will be quick to highlight the considerable impact that he has made at the club since arriving in January.

(Photo by Mike Hewitt/Getty Images)

The 26-year-old was signed from Ruben Kazan for an undisclosed fee six months ago and he produced a string of hugely impressive performances as he cemented his place in the starting eleven.

In what was a disappointing season that ultimately ended in relegation, Bauer was one of the few bright sparks that supporters could take some heart from.

He made 15 appearances in total with his energy, enthusiasm and pace enabling him to easily make the transition into a prominent performer in the Premier League.

Bauer is naturally a full-back and he proved to be equally adept at undertaking his defensive responsibilities as he was driving forward with the ball or making overlapping runs into the opposition half.

He ended the campaign being used as a winger as Paul Lambert struggled to find a solution to the team’s woes on the pitch but he undoubtedly applied himself to the best of his ability.

Immediately following relegation the Austrian publicly announced that he would be happy to remain at the Bet365 Stadium and it is refreshing to see a player showing a degree of loyalty to a club that he had only recently joined.

The fact that he signed a new contract at the start of the month confirmed that he was a man of his word and leaves Stoke having signed what will be the best attacking fullback that you are likely to see in the Championship this year.

(Photo  by Oli Scarff/Getty Images)

Bauer’s natural athleticism combined with his technical ability will make him a force to be reckoned with in the second tier and, if used as a fullback, his overlapping runs will add another string to Stoke’s attacking repertoire.

If supporters thought that he had adapted well to life in the Premier League then they will be licking their lips at the prospect of him being unleashed in the Championship.

The 26-year-old’s new contract has continued to add to the feel-good factor surrounding the Bet365 Stadium during the summer and there is a real sense of positivity around the club.

Rowett’s side are among the favourites for promotion and his activities so far as manager, both in terms of new arrivals and persuading key squad members to stay, clearly demonstrates his intentions.

Bauer possesses all of the attributes to be a star for Stoke in the Championship and he will be a key feature in the team are to immediately bounce back into the Premier League.

The best attacking fullback in the Championship? We will have to wait and see.

Continue Reading


Copyright © 2018 The Boot Room.