Connect with us

Manchester United

What prompted Jose Mourinho’s ‘shush’ gesture and is he really an “enemy of football”?

Martyn Cooke



On Saturday afternoon, as the final whistle blew at Old Trafford, Jose Mourinho put a finger to his lips, strode towards the nearest television camera and made a ‘shush’ gesture that was both distinctive and unmistakable.

It was a brief moment of relief from a man who clearly feels that he has been treated unfairly in recent weeks both by the media and, to a much lesser extent at the weekend, by a small section of Manchester United supporters. His post-match gesture was fuelled by a vital victory against Tottenham Hotspur and a feeling of unmerited condemnation of his team’s recent performances – it was a direct response to his doubters and detractors.

The past fortnight has undoubtedly been a challenging period for Mourinho and Manchester United. The Portuguese maestro was widely criticised for his tactical approach at Anfield two weeks ago, which produced a dull goalless draw, with further pressure added when his side slumped to a surprise defeat against newly promoted Huddersfield Town.

After eighty minutes of the contest against Tottenham on Saturday, another dull affair which seemed destined to end in a bore-draw, Mourinho was jeered by some supporters for his decision to replace Marcus Rashford with Anthony Martial.

After the draw against Liverpool, Mourinho was branded as “the enemy of football” by the Daily Mail for his conservatism and pragmatism and, at Old Trafford, he was being rounded upon by a portion of his own fan-base.

The irony of cause was that Martial would grab United’s winning goal, which empowered Mourinho to respond to his critics with his distinctive gesture at the final whistle. The combination of, what one can only assume that the 54-year-old believes is, an unfair, criticism of his approach, alongside the response of the Old Trafford faithful, appears to have tweaked a nerve.

Naturally, this provoked a definitive response from the Portuguese coach.

“Enemy of football”?

Whether the criticism that Manchester United have received in recent weeks is warranted is open to debate.

It is hard to deny that the performances against Liverpool and Tottenham Hotspur were anything other than dull contests – far from being the thrilling fixtures that the media had built them up to be.

There is also a degree of truth that Jose Mourinho could have utilised a more forward-thinking approach in both of those matches, especially considering the fact that he spent another £100 million on new players during the close-season.

Yet, in contrast, any team that faces a trip to Anfield and a contest against an in-form Tottenham side would be delighted to walk away with four points on the board. That will certainly be Mourinho’s argument – his pragmatism may not have excited the casual observer but the points secured by utilising a conservative approach may turn out to be crucial at the end of the campaign.

If United lift the Premier League title when the season concludes there will be few supporters that will reflect on those four points as anything other than two vital results.

It also takes two to tango. Whilst Mourinho may have set up his team to be defensively solid against Liverpool and Tottenham it is worth noting that neither Jurgen Klopp nor Mauricio Pochettino were prepared to unshackle their own players when they faced United.

Mourinho has a reputation for employing a pragmatic, win-at-all-costs philosophy, in which securing silverware by any means necessary is the only thing that matters. This is a common misconception, both historically and in the present day.

United are the second-highest goal scorers in the Premier League this season and have found the net on more occasions than any of their title rivals barring Manchester City, who are admittedly operating on a different level than any other English club at the moment.

The Reds have been more productive in front of goal than Tottenham, despite the fact that Spurs are widely lauded for their expansive football, and have scored three or more goal in seven of their fourteen fixtures across all competitions.

This hardly indicates that United under Mourinho are any less expansive or exciting to watch than the majority of their rivals.

Even in his previous roles at various clubs across Europe the evidence suggests that the Portuguese coach is far from pragmatic. During the 2011/12 season his Real Madrid side secured the Spanish title with a record number of points (100), a record number of goals scored (121) and a record number of victories (32).

Even in England, during his debut season at Stamford Bridge, Chelsea won the Premier League with a record haul of 95 points.

Pep Guardiola has changed the dynamics of English football

So is Jose Mourinho really the “enemy of football”? The evidence certain suggests that his Manchester United side is one of the most effective and expansive in England in terms of scoring goals.

There is often the lazy and heart-hearted comparison made between the current United side and the renowned teams that were constructed by Sir Alex Ferguson during the 1990s and early 2000s.

The Scotsman, who is undoubtedly one of the most successful football managers in the history of the game, is often presented as promoting swash-buckling, expansive football at Old Trafford – this is often a rose-tinted reflection on his spell with the club.

Whilst his reign was certainly characterised by exciting football Ferguson’s teams also knew how to grind out a gritty, messy one goal victory when they were required to.

And what if Mourinho is pragmatic at times?

Manchester United are a club that has struggled to emerge out of the Ferguson’s shadow following his retirement – his immediate successors struggled to bring any sort of silverware or success to Old Trafford.

However, under Mourinho the club have already secured one League Cup and Europa League triumph and one can only assume that they will be the first of many.

If the Portuguese coach is able to add further trophies to the Old Trafford trophy cabinet, of which both David Moyes and Louis Van Gall struggled to achieve, then why is winning ugly from time to time such a bad thing? Since when has winning been a stick to beat a manager with?

The problem for Mourinho is that just across Manchester Pep Guardiola has unleashed his total football revolution onto an unsuspecting Premier League.

Manchester City have made an astonishing start to the Spaniard’s second season in English football, both in terms of results and the style of play that has been deployed.

Guardiola has suddenly raised the bar in terms of what is expected of the so-called ‘big-six’ clubs, which has heaped an unexpected amount of pressure on Mourinho’s shoulders.

In any normal season, United’s start to the campaign would see them sitting two or three points clear at the top of the table, yet City’s emergence as a genuine superpower has altered the dynamics and boundaries.

The one thing that you can guarantee, though, is that Mourinho will be determined to re-established United as the leading club in Manchester. He has been a thorn in Guardiola’s side in the past and you would not bet against him responding to his critics and the pressure from across the city with a title triumph.

Come the end of the season, if United do beat their local rivals to the title, not one supporter inside Old Trafford will be the slightest bit bothered how they achieved it.

Jose Mourinho, the ‘enemy of football’? I think not.

Martyn is currently a PTA and Research Assistant in the Department of Exercise Science at the Manchester Metropolitan University (MMU). In addition to his teaching role he is also undertaking a PhD in Sports History that is exploring the origins and development of football in Staffordshire. Prior to working at MMU, Martyn spent a decade operating in the sport and leisure industry in a variety of roles including as a Sports Development Officers, PE Teacher, Football Coach and Operation Manager.

Huddersfield Town

Huddersfield Town 0-2 Manchester United: Three talking points from the John Smith’s Stadium

Rob Meech brings us three talking points from the John Smith’s Stadium as Manchester United overcame Huddersfield Town in their FA Cup 5th Round contest.

Rob Meech



Photo: Reuters

A brace from sharpshooter Romelu Lukaku fired Manchester United into the quarter-finals of the FA Cup at the expense of Huddersfield Town.

Lukaku opened his account in the third minute before netting his second of the evening shortly after the second-half resumption.

Victory was not as straightforward as the scoreline suggested. However, as the Terriers produced a spirited display after the early setback.

There was also controversy involving the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system.

Juan Mata saw an effort ruled out for offside after a review, but confusion abounded about whether it had been the correct decision.

Here are three talking points from an eventful encounter, as United set up a last-eight tie with Brighton & Hove Albion…

Lukaku’s goals are a fillip for Jose Mourinho

The Belgian has come in for criticism from some quarters for his goal return since last summer’s big-money transfer from Everton.

While he may not have reached the levels of Harry Kane or Mohamed Salah, Lukaku has now scored 21 times in all competitions for United this season.

That tally was boosted by his double against Huddersfield, which showed off his best attributes.

Lukaku was too strong and clever for Huddersfield’s defence as he latched on to Mata’s through ball for the first, before putting the finishing touch to an Alexis Sanchez pass for his second.

The former Chelsea man’s performance will be the biggest plus for United boss Jose Mourinho, who is relying on him to spearhead the attack for the remainder of the campaign.

Lukaku is a confidence player, so this was a timely boost ahead of a crucial run of fixtures both domestically and in Europe.

VAR under the microscope yet again

The introduction of technology to any sport usually results in teething problems.

It is fair to say VAR has experienced more than its fair share in football this season.

Employed in some FA and League Cup matches, controversy has never been far away. This was again the case at Huddersfield.

Mata appeared to have doubled United’s lead just before half-time, but referee Kevin Friend waited for confirmation from VAR that he had been onside.

After about a minute, Friend disallowed the goal when it was judged that Mata had been fractionally offside as the ball was played.

Contention emerged when viewers saw the incident on TV, where the guidelines were clearly not straight.

In fact, they were embarrassingly wonky.

Further replays suggested – with parallel lines correctly in place – that Mata’s knee had indeed been offside, but it was a very close call and certainly not an obvious mistake by the referee’s assistant.

These technical hitches will need to be ironed out before VAR is brought in universally.

Huddersfield can be positive despite FA Cup exit

With their Premier League status hanging in the balance, it would have been understandable if Huddersfield manager David Wagner had seen this fixture as an unwanted distraction.

But there was absolutely no suggestion that they were trying not to win the match, or prepared to exit the competition without a fight.

The Terriers, who famously beat United at home in the Premier League last October, carried on from where they left off last weekend in the impressive 4-1 victory over Bournemouth.

Conceding so early to United had not been in the script, but the hosts regrouped quickly and caused their opponents plenty of problems.

Ultimately, the difference between the two sides was the quality of finishing.

Whereas the visitors scored with their only two shots on target, Huddersfield wasted numerous openings as they slipped to defeat.

Nevertheless, attention can be turned back to their bid for survival, without their confidence dented.

Continue Reading

English Premier League

Newcastle United 1-0 Manchester United: Three talking points from St James’ Park

Jake Jackman




Newcastle United delivered one of their best performances of the season as they overcame Manchester United in a hard-fought victory. Due to Huddersfield Town’s win earlier in the day, the Magpies started the match in the relegation zone and only three points would see them climb out of the bottom three. That is exactly what they got as they ran themselves into the ground to beat a more talented top-six team. This was the club’s first win at St James’ Park since October and it came at a crucial time. Here are three talking points from the game:

Martin Dubravka shone on his debut

Although Newcastle didn’t do a great deal of business during the January transfer window, they did make three loan signings and one of them was the star of the show on Sunday. Martin Dubravka came in for his Magpies’ debut as he replaced Karl Darlow in goal and it would have been easy to be daunted by the occasion, but the Slovakian international took it in his stride. He was near faultless, as he made a number of crucial saves and marshalled his box effectively.

Benitez has wanted a new goalkeeper since he took over at the club, but last summer’s signing Matz Sels didn’t adjust to English football and that left the manager with the problem that he inherited. Karl Darlow and Rob Elliot have shared the duties of being number one, but neither have stood out as being Premier League quality.

The addition of Dubravka supplied instant benefits, as he was quick to claim crosses and had an excellent control of his area. In the first-half, he made a crucial stop to deny Anthony Martial. With just minutes left, he made an incredible reaction save to make sure Newcastle kept hold of the clean sheet. It was a debut to remember and on this evidence, the Slovakian will be the number one at St James’ Park for the rest of the campaign.

Manchester United lacked options to change the game

There were some strange decisions made by Jose Mourinho as he tried to change the game in his side’s favour in the second half. He brought on Michael Carrick and Juan Mata for Paul Pogba and Jesse Lingard. This change arguably made them more predictable in attack, as the two players coming on had less pace and dynamism. The third change saw youngster Scott McTominay come on for Nemanja Matic. It was a tough ask for the inexperienced midfielder to get Manchester United back in to the game.

Although the changes arguably made the team worse, there were few options available to Mourinho, as Zlatan Ibrahimovic, Ander Herrera and Marcus Rashford were all missing from the squad. Marcos Rojo and Luke Shaw were on the bench, but neither are attacking players and that is what Manchester United needed.

Paul Pogba looked jaded and lacking fitness for the entire ninety minutes, but he was forced to start due to the lack of other options on Sunday. It is no excuse, but the inability to change the game did leave Mourinho short, especially after falling behind.

Newcastle won the midfield battle

As alluded to above, Paul Poba didn’t look fully fit and Newcastle United took full advantage of that as they won the midfield battle. Mohamed Diame was a figure of frustration for the first-half of the season, but he has improved significantly in recent weeks. He and Jonjo Shelvey were both superb, as they fought hard and distributed the ball well when they had the opportunity to. Between them, they made 13 ball recoveries and five key passes. They fully committed to the cause and played a vital role in the team’s victory.

The renaissance of Diame has been incredible to watch as he is now performing to the level that Rafa Benitez would have expected when he was signed last summer. However, the improvement of Shelvey could prove to be even more important in the long run. The midfielder has been difficult to manage at times due to his ability to lose his head on the pitch. On Sunday, he was a professional and remained focused, which was a mental victory for him.

The Magpies manager and the supporters will be hoping he can continue to perform to this level. If he can, the former Swansea City midfielder can be the player that everybody knows he can become.

Continue Reading


Which four of the ‘big-six’ clubs will qualify for next season’s Champions League?

Martyn Cooke



There are just 12 games remaining of the current Premier League season and, with Manchester City seemingly destined to secure the title, attention will now turn towards the battle to secure a place in the top-four.

There are only three places available to share between Manchester United, Arsenal, Tottenham Hotspur, Chelsea and Liverpool and two of those clubs will be have to be content with competing in the Europa League next season.

Here, The Boot Room predicts who will finish in the top four at the end of the season…


There was once a time when the possibility of Arsene Wenger and Arsenal failing to qualify for the Champions League was unthinkable, yet the Gunners are facing the realistic possibility of missing out on playing in Europe’s elite club competition for the second consecutive season.

This campaign they have been held back by their inconsistent and unpredictable form away from home and are playing catch-up with their rivals with a five-point gap emerging between themselves and fourth place.

There is a new sense of optimism around the Emirates Stadium after Wenger added Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang and Henrikh Mkhitaryan to his squad yet a defeat against Tottenham Hotspur on Saturday would all but end their hopes – qualifying through winning the Europa League could be a more realistic option.

Prediction: 6th

Manchester United

There is currently a slight sense of disappointment around Old Trafford this season that, despite obvious progress since the arrival of Jose Mourinho, the club have had to be content with seeing cross-city rivals Manchester City stroll their way towards the Premier League title.

It is difficult to imagine Manchester United missing out on a Champions League place as they already have a considerable buffer of seven points and undoubtedly have a squad that is full of quality and experience.

The arrival of Alexis Sanchez will provide additional impetus in the closing stages of the campaign and the only real danger is that their attention might be redirected towards challenging for the Champions League or FA Cup with the title already all but lost.

However, Mouirnho has his team ticking over nicely and it is likely that they will maintain their current league position.

Prediction: 2nd  


It has been a frustrating and increasing turbulent season at Stamford Bridge following the failure of Chelsea to build on last season’s title triumph.

Back-to-back defeats against Bournemouth and Watford have left the Blues clinging on to their place in the top four and there is now a realistic possibility that they may miss out on Champions League qualification.

Antonio Conte’s frustration with the club’s transfer policy has been clear to see since the summer and the off-pitch squabbling can only be a destabilising influence for the players.

Chelsea are certainly a team that are out of form and appear to be short of confidence and direction and it will be a true test of Conte’s managerial prowess to see if he can facilitate some sort of revival in the closing months of the season.

However, momentum is currently against them and they may well be one of the two clubs to miss out.

Prediction: 6th


You get the sense that it is always two steps forward followed by one step back at Anfield under Jurgen Klopp and you never know quite what to expect.

Liverpool continue to be consistently inconsistent as demonstrated by their recent, contrasting performances against Manchester City and Swansea City.

The arrival of Virgil van Dijk in the January transfer window is a boost, although recent games have suggested that he alone will not solve the club’s defensive frailties, whilst the sale of Phillip Coutinho is offset by the impressive array of attacking players that Klopp has collected.

If Liverpool can put together a good run of results then they will be able to capitalise on Antonio Conte’s woes as Chelsea and finish in the top four.

Prediction: 4th

Tottenham Hotspur

Tottenham Hotspur supporters will now have a taste for Champions League football after the success of their team in this year’s competition and they are hitting form at just the right moment in the Premier League.

Mauricio Pochettino’s side are unbeaten since mid-December and have plenty of momentum with the inspirational figure of Harry Kane continuing to his remarkable, prolific run of form in front of goal.

Much will depend on whether the England striker can stay fit until the end of the season whilst they also need Dele Alli to rediscover the sparkle that he has lost in recent months.

Tottenham face a season-defining fixture on Saturday when they face Arsenal in the North London derby but they should have enough quality to qualify for next season’s Champions League.

Prediction: 3rd

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2017 The Boot Room.